Where To Find This Example
AWR Version 14
This example was named in V14, please see 8GHz_BPF_Model_Comparison
AWR Version 13
Select Help > Open Examples... from the menus and type either the example name listed above or one of the keywords below.
Or in Version 13 you can open the project directly from this page using this button.
Band-Pass Filter Comparison:
This example shows a band-pass filter simulated using three different technologies within MWO. The filter is designed using conventional models, EM-based models (XModels), and EM Extraction to produce an actual EM simulation. As the "Return Loss" and "Transmission" plots show, the XModel design offers greater accuracy over conventional models similar to those used in other simulators.
XModels Versus Traditional Models
Traditional closed form distributed models were developed to be usable over a wide range of parameter values (like line width, substrate height, substrate relative permittivity for a microstrip line). These models make a tradeoff in accuracy for a wide range of parameters where they are accurate. When doing a design, the substrate characteristics are fixed. The XModels create a model specific for a particular substrate and are extremely accurate. These models are created using the built-in EM simulator of Microwave Office which allows new substrate models to easily be created.
For further help on the use of X-Models, and how they are generated, please review the Users Guide on EM-Based Discontinuity Models.
EM Extraction was used to produce EM structure "Extraction_Using_Traditional_Models". When you simulate the project as given, you can see the results of an actual EM simulation and compare those to the results from schematics "Traditional_Models" and "X_Models". To watch the actual EM Extraction process, simply delete EM structure "Extraction_Using_Traditional_Models" and re-simulate the project. Note that it will take a few minutes to perform the EM Extraction.
For further help on the use of EM Extraction, please review the Users Guide on Creating EM Structures with Extraction.
Schematic - X_Models
Schematic - Traditional_Models_Extract
EM Structure - Extraction_Using_Traditional_Models
Graph - Transmission
Graph - Smith Chart
Graph - Return Loss